Form a Point of View
Produce a decisive, project-grounded point of view in the subject's own shape: a graded verdict on an external-adoption question, a holistic take on a document, or a position on a supplied approach set. The subject is whatever this skill was invoked with, in the prompt or the conversation. Stay read-only while forming and reconciling the POV. You are done when the POV is delivered with its attribution and required disclosure, or when an explicit blocker is returned. The year is 2026, for source recency.
The moat
Never issue a POV you did not earn against the project's own context. Every subject must clear the
project floor in
. An external-adoption verdict must also clear the full external floor. A document or approach-set POV must externally verify any external claim that is load-bearing to its bottom line. Nothing the conversation asserts substitutes for grounding.
User-facing communication
Write for the person deciding what to do. Lead with the decision, question, or recommendation. Keep internal workflow vocabulary and mechanics out of chat unless asked, and put any consequence they need into ordinary language. Call the codebase "this project" or "the repository" unless the user supplied a recognizable name. Never promote a directory, worktree, checkout, branch, or path into the project name.
Interaction Method
Ask through the host's blocking question tool, one question at a time:
(Claude Code; run
with
if its schema is not loaded),
(Codex),
(
),
(Pi). Fall back to numbered chat options only when none exists or the call errors. Never skip the question.
Artifact Root
Resolve
the first time you compose a
path; a read of
counts as composing one. Pass the resolved path to scouts, never the config. A non-git project has no
, so its prior-decision scan uses local ADRs and design docs instead.
<!-- ce-docs-root:start -->
Resolve the CE artifact root before composing any artifact path.
- Read from
<repo-root>/.compound-engineering/config.yaml
git rev-parse --show-toplevel
- Validate a set value: a repo-relative directory whose real, symlink-resolved path stays inside the repo and is neither the repo root nor under . Otherwise stop with an error naming and the value -- never fall back to .
- Use as the sole artifact location: create it if absent, compose each path as with this skill's own subdirectory, and never also read .
<!-- ce-docs-root:end -->
Phase 0: Frame and Classify
Read now, before any grounding. It owns the output mode, the warm-invocation contract, orientation and framing, sizing, and the unbounded-field escape hatch. Settle the subject and the POV intent there (adopt / migrate / compare / is-this-our-problem / Document-take / Approach-set / explainer); an intent that routes out finishes at intake, and one that continues settles a reversibility tier. Read
when this skill's fit is in doubt.
Phase 1: Ground
Read now, before grounding by either path. It owns the model tiers (the POV reasoning itself is never dispatched), the scratch fence, the scout payload and fleet, capability gating, and the provenance buckets that keep grounded facts apart from unconfirmed ones.
Send scouts directly to candidate-specific current evidence, never a generic repo profile. They search in their own context and return a dossier path plus a gist, which you read on demand. Where the load-bearing facts are already located, confirm them with bounded reads of the authoritative source instead of dispatching scouts; unscoped or noisy grounding still dispatches. A claim made in the conversation is a pointer to check, never self-verifying. The prior-decision scan (
, ADRs, design docs) stays mandatory on either path.
Phase 2: Verify Grounding
Read now, before reasoning about the POV. It owns the Verify and POV steps, the skeptic stance, tiering, and the gate. Apply that gate over the grounded evidence. A failed floor forbids a confident result in any subject shape; that reference names the failure result each shape returns instead.
Phase 3: Point of View
First form ce-pov's own independent POV under the active subject-shape contract in
, but do not emit it. Freeze that position. Keep it out of an independent peer's initial context; expose it only when the task is to critique that position, or in a later reconciliation round.
A summons is an affirmative request to consult or reconcile peers — a panel, a cross-check,
— anywhere in the invocation context. Declining one, or merely recounting one, is not a summons. On a summons, or when a cold POV may qualify for a proactive offer, read
references/cross-model-panel.md
before resolving participation or deciding whether to offer. Finish the panel branch before composing the result. A POV that follows a summons states which peers ran, or that none did and why. A POV with no summons carries no panel note.
Only then emit the subject shape's contract, as a compact chat block, not a research report. Lead with the grade, bottom line, or position, and never reprint dossiers or raw output.
Phase 4: Follow-up
The chat POV is the deliverable; implementation is not.
Read for the four-part handoff gate, the routing, and the continuations. Hand the POV on without another question only when that gate passes. Otherwise offer one continuation and wait. Reason that offer from the active subject shape's result — external adoption, Document take, or Approach-set position — never from a fixed menu, and never assume everything routes to a plan. Block only where that reference says the user must choose.
Warm invocations stay a guest: output the POV block, hand control back, and offer none of this unless asked.