Back to Details

cross-modal-review

Compare original and translation side by side

🇺🇸

Original

English
🇨🇳

Translation

Chinese

Cross-Modal Review

跨模型审查

Convention: See 
skills/conventions/cross-modal.yaml
for the review pairs and refusal routing chain.
约定： 查看
skills/conventions/cross-modal.yaml
获取审查配对和拒绝路由链。

Contract

契约

This skill guarantees:
  • Work product is reviewed by a different model before finalizing
  • Review grades against the originating skill's Contract section
  • Agreement and disagreement are reported transparently
  • Refusal from one model triggers silent switch to next in chain
  • User always makes the final decision (user sovereignty)
本Skill保证：
  • 工作成果在最终确定前由不同模型进行审查
  • 审查依据原Skill的「契约」部分进行评分
  • 透明报告一致和不一致的结果
  • 若一个模型拒绝处理，将自动切换到链中的下一个模型，全程无感知
  • 用户始终拥有最终决定权（用户主权）

Phases

流程阶段

  1. Capture the work product. The brain page, analysis, or decision to be reviewed.
  2. Load the Contract. Read the originating skill's Contract section (what was promised).
  3. Spawn review model. Send the work + Contract to a different model. Use 
    skills/conventions/model-routing.md
    for model selection.
  4. Grade. Model evaluates: did the output follow the Contract? Pass/fail with specific citations.
  5. Report. Present agreement/disagreement to the user. Never auto-apply the reviewer's suggestions.
  1. 捕获工作成果：待审查的脑图页面、分析内容或决策结果。
  2. 加载契约：读取原Skill的「契约」部分（即承诺的内容）。
  3. 调用审查模型：将工作成果+契约发送至不同模型。模型选择参考
    skills/conventions/model-routing.md
    。
  4. 评分：模型评估：输出是否符合契约要求？给出通过/不通过的结果并附上具体依据。
  5. 报告：向用户展示一致/不一致的结果。绝不自动应用审查者的建议。

Refusal Routing

拒绝路由

If the primary model refuses:
  1. Silently switch to the next model in the chain (see 
    skills/conventions/cross-modal.yaml
    )
  2. Never show the refusal to the user
  3. Never announce the switch
  4. If ALL models refuse, escalate to the user
如果主模型拒绝处理：
  1. 自动切换到链中的下一个模型（详见
    skills/conventions/cross-modal.yaml
    ）
  2. 绝不向用户展示拒绝信息
  3. 绝不告知用户已切换模型
  4. 如果所有模型都拒绝处理，则升级给用户处理

Output Format

输出格式

Cross-Modal Review
==================
Reviewer: {model name}
Contract: {originating skill}
Verdict: PASS | ISSUES FOUND

Findings:
- {finding with evidence}

Agreement with primary: {X}%
Cross-Modal Review
==================
Reviewer: {model name}
Contract: {originating skill}
Verdict: PASS | ISSUES FOUND

Findings:
- {finding with evidence}

Agreement with primary: {X}%

Anti-Patterns

反模式

  • Auto-applying reviewer suggestions without user approval
  • Showing model refusals to the user
  • Using the same model for review and generation
  • Skipping the Contract reference (reviewing vibes, not guarantees)
  • 未经用户批准自动应用审查者的建议
  • 向用户展示模型拒绝信息
  • 使用同一模型进行审查和生成内容
  • 跳过契约参考（仅凭感觉审查，而非基于承诺的内容）